A draw on Saturday means the National League side will face the National League South team again, writes Tom Feaheny.
"I'm not disappointed with the result, we faced a team in good form but I felt some of our play at times was very poor," Garrard said.
"They are very disciplined and organised, their set-pieces are good and they have good players, I have to give credit to them."
"Our play show us putting the ball into the right area but without any real quality."
"We now have the chance to right a wrong on Tuesday, the fans have seen what we are about and now we must react."
For more news, reaction and action from across the National League, like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter and Instagram.